November 20, 2026

Dear Interested Readers,

 

Confusion and Chaos: A Poupouri of Possibilities

 

My wildest dream did come true. The midterm elections did exceed my expectations. Now the big question is how the huge Democratic Congressional majorities can best be used to begin to reverse the damage that President Trump and HHS Secretary Kennedy have done to access to care, the cost of care, public health initiatives, medical science, and our participation in international efforts to improve the health of those living in poverty around the world while monitoring for early intervention in potential pandemics. 

 

Pundits in newspapers and online have offered their opinions. In truth, the path forward will probably be directed by Hakeem Jeffries, the choice of the Democratic majority as Speaker of the House. Chuck Schumer and Chris Van Hollen are running for Senate Majority Leader, and that contest won’t be decided until early December. The Senate does not have a veto-proof majority, so some transactions with the president will be required for any legislation to be passed.

 

Fortunately, when it is time to negotiate with the president, his cruelty and ego may be partially balanced by his transactional approach to business. It will be interesting to see if his “art of the deal” can be turned against him and translated into his signing a few critical pieces of legislation that might cut healthcare losses and allow us to resume the slow journey toward something like the Triple Aim even before he leaves office in January 2029. An even less likely path might be the passage of bipartisan legislation supported by enough Republican senators to be “veto-proof.” Miracles have already occurred this year. Is there a possibility for more?

 

One very controversial issue when the new Senate is seated in January is whether or not the Democratic majority will vote to end the filibuster. Over the years, the filibuster went from a maneuver to delay cloture, the vote to end debate on a bill, by holding the floor of the Senate with marathon speeches, to a process that required supermajority votes of 67%, and then modification to only 60% with intent only and no speeches required.

 

A significant modification, among many, was to exempt revenue- or budget-related bills from the filibuster and allow cloture by a simple majority in a process called “budget reconciliation.” That modification has led to a lot of policy being enacted by lumping many issues into one huge bill, like the recently passed “One Big Beautiful [or ugly] Bill. The passage of the ACA also required the use of “reconciliation.” When Ted Kennedy died, his seat was ultimately taken by Republican Scott Brown, and the Democrats had only 59 votes, which was one short of the number needed to override a filibuster, which meant that the ACA had to be presented as a budget issue and go the way of reconciliation, which prevented further modification of the bill and required the House to accept the Senate form of the legislation where Independent Joe Lieberman had forced the elimination of a “public option.”

 

Given the long evolution of the filibuster into its present form, I decided to ask Google Gemini for an overview of its history. If you aren’t interested, just skip it by jumping past its italicized description:

 

The filibuster—a U.S. Senate tactic used to delay or block a vote through extended debate—was not part of the Founding Fathers’ original constitutional design, but rather emerged by accident from an early rulebook cleanup in 1806. Over two centuries, it evolved from a rare marathon speech into a routine procedural requirement for passing most legislation. [1, 2, 3]

Origins and Early History (1789–1917)

  • Ancient Precedents. Legislative obstruction dates back to the Roman Republic, where Senator Cato the Younger famously gave all-day speeches to block votes supported by Julius Caesar. [1, 2]
  • The 1806 Rule Change. In 1789, both the House and Senate used a “previous question” motion that allowed a simple majority to end debate. In 1805, Vice President Aaron Burr advised the Senate to streamline its rules by dropping this rarely used motion, and the Senate officially removed it in 1806. While the House kept the rule to manage its growing size, the Senate was left with no mechanism to force a vote. [1, 2, 3]
  • The First Filibusters. Senators did not immediately exploit this loophole. The first true Senate filibuster occurred in 1837, and the tactic became more prominent in the 1840s under Senator John C. Calhoun to protect Southern slaveholding interests. The term “filibuster”—derived from a Dutch word for “pirate” used to describe rogue adventurers—entered congressional vocabulary in the 1850s to describe senators hijacking the floor. [1, 2, 3, 4]

The Introduction of Cloture and the Civil Rights Era (1917–1960s)

  • Rule XXII (1917). During World War I, a small group of anti-war senators successfully filibustered President Woodrow Wilson’s bill to arm U.S. merchant ships. In response, the Senate adopted Rule XXII, creating “cloture”—a procedure allowing a two-thirds supermajority of senators present and voting to end debate. [1, 2, 3, 4]
  • Tool Against Civil Rights. Throughout the 1920s, 1930s, and 1950s, Southern senators frequently used the filibuster to block anti-lynching bills, voting rights protections, and desegregation measures. During this era, senators had to physically hold the floor, leading to famous endurance speeches like Huey Long’s 15-hour speech in 1935 and Strom Thurmond’s 24-hour, 18-minute speech against the Civil Rights Act of 1957. [1, 2, 3]
  • Breaking the Gridlock. In 1964, supporters of the Civil Rights Act successfully invoked cloture after a 60-day filibuster, marking a major turning point in overcoming minority obstruction on civil rights. [1]

The Modern “60-Vote” Senate (1970s–Present)

  • The Two-Track System and 1975 Reform. In the early 1970s, Senate leadership introduced a “two-track” system allowing the chamber to set aside a filibustered bill and move on to other business. In 1975, the Senate lowered the cloture threshold from two-thirds of those voting to three-fifths of all sworn senators—setting the modern 60-vote requirement. [1, 2, 3]
  • Rise of the “Silent” Filibuster. Because the two-track system meant a filibuster no longer paralyzed the entire Senate, senators no longer needed to stand and speak. Merely threatening a filibuster became enough to stall a bill unless the majority could muster 60 votes, causing the number of cloture motions to skyrocket from dozens per decade to hundreds per congressional session. [1, 2]
  • Carve-Outs and the “Nuclear Option.” Over time, Congress created statutory exceptions—most notably budget reconciliation, which allows certain spending and tax bills to pass with a simple majority. Additionally, frustration over blocked nominations led both parties to use the “nuclear option,” a procedural move that alters Senate precedent by a simple majority vote:
  • 2013: Senate Democrats eliminated the 60-vote threshold for executive branch nominees and federal judicial nominees below the Supreme Court.
  • 2017: Senate Republicans extended that simple-majority rule to Supreme Court nominations. [1, 2, 3, 4]

Today, while individual senators occasionally still stage marathon speeches for publicity or protest—such as Senator Cory Booker’s 25-hour, 5-minute speech in 2025—the legislative filibuster remains intact for standard bills, effectively requiring a 60-vote coalition to pass most major legislation. [1, 2]

 

The appeal of the filibuster has been that it allows a minority to block legislation that it doesn’t like. Since the filibuster can be modified by the majority party, as it was in 2017 when a Republican majority eliminated the filibuster for Supreme Court appointments, a legitimate question is why does a majority in any party allow it to persist? The answer is that senators of the majority party fear what might happen if the minority party comes to power with the next election. Given the composition of the Senate, with states with smaller populations like Vermont, Alaska, and Wyoming having the same number of senators as more populated states like California, Texas, and New York, the Senate, by its design, violates the concept of one person, one vote and is protective of the political influence of the minority of Americans who live in smaller states. 

 

The most egregious use of the filibuster in history was the way Southern Democrats were able to use it during the Jim Crow era to avoid anti-lynching legislation and delay civil rights legislation for a century. In our era, it has made healthcare legislation more difficult. On the positive side, over the last two years, it has prevented the passage of legislation sponsored by President Trump, the SAVE Act, that would have created even greater barriers to voting. You win some and lose some with the filibuster.

 

It would seem that a move to kill the filibuster, or even to further modify it to exempt certain new legislation from its impact, will require courage. Those who wish to abolish it, like me, must be willing to risk future oppressive legislation to pass critically needed legislation in the moment. Those who would like to see it go away point to the reality that if oppressive legislation is passed by a simple majority, there is always the next election where those politicians who turned detrimental policies into new laws could be voted out of office. That was at least part of the explanation for the Democratic Party’s huge victory in the midterm elections. Maybe we owe a big thanks to Senate Majority Leader John Thune, who resisted Trump’s demands to end the filibuster so that his oppressive voting law, the SAVE Act, could pass. 

 

So, I decided to ask ChatGPT what options the Democrats would have if they were reluctant to end the filibuster. It is a complex question. I have my own ideas, but I wanted a quick overview that includes things that I might not consider, so I asked:

 

Assuming the Democrats don’t eliminate the filibuster, what can the Democratically controlled Congress do to begin reversing the damage to healthcare access, costs, and research caused by President Trump’s policies and the One Big Beautiful Bill?

 

ChatGPT quickly responded:

 

Even without eliminating the Senate filibuster, a Democratic-controlled Congress has several legislative, budgetary, and oversight tools to begin rolling back the healthcare provisions of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) and related Trump administration policies. However, because President Trump remains in the White House with veto power, congressional Democrats must balance unilateral party-line maneuvers with targeted bipartisan negotiations. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]

 

That is exactly what I was trying to say! But ChatGPT had more to add, which you can also skip by scrolling past the italics if you like, since I am going to repeat some of it in my further comments, as repetition is a good way to emphasize something important.

 

  1. Budget Reconciliation (Bypassing the Filibuster)

Because Republicans passed the OBBBA using the budget reconciliation process, Democrats can use the exact same mechanism to undo its core spending and tax provisions with a simple 51-vote majority in the Senate. [1, 2]

  • Reversing Medicaid Cuts and Work Requirements. Democrats can pass a reconciliation package that repeals the OBBBA’s roughly $1 trillion in Medicaid reductions, eliminates the 80-hour-per-month work reporting requirements, and cancels mandates for biannual eligibility checks. [1, 2, 3]
  • Restoring Enhanced ACA Subsidies. Through reconciliation, Congress can reinstate the enhanced Affordable Care Act (ACA) premium tax credits that expired at the end of 2025, which directly lowers monthly insurance premiums for marketplace enrollees. [1, 2, 3]
  • The Veto Hurdle. While reconciliation gets bills past the Senate filibuster, President Trump can still veto the resulting package. According to political analysts, passing a reconciliation bill forces Republicans on the record regarding popular health programs and creates a high-stakes negotiation point ahead of the 2028 elections. [1, 2]
  1. Leverage in “Must-Pass” Appropriations Bills

Regular government funding bills and debt-ceiling measures require 60 votes in the Senate and cannot pass without Democratic support. [1, 2]

  • Protecting and Restoring Research Funding. Democrats can use the annual appropriations process to block executive branch efforts to slash budgets at the National Institutes of Health (NIH), Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), and other federal research agencies. They can also insert explicit statutory language prohibiting the administration from freezing or redirecting congressionally approved research grants. [1]
  • Negotiating Policy Riders and Delays. As noted by KFF Executive Vice President Larry Levitt, Democrats can withhold votes on must-pass spending bills to extract concessions from the White House. These deals could include temporary extensions of ACA subsidies or partial delays of Medicaid coverage restrictions in exchange for administration priorities, such as expanded Health Savings Accounts (HSAs). [1]
  • Targeted Bipartisan Repeals. Some Republican lawmakers have expressed concern over the implementation of steep Medicaid reductions in their states. Sen. Tim Kaine noted an “open door” for bipartisan talks to delay or soften scheduled OBBBA cuts—such as provider tax caps and rural hospital funding shortfalls—before they fully phase in through 2028. [1, 2]
  1. Bipartisan Cost-Containment Legislation

To get bills signed into law without triggering a veto, Democrats can pursue structural cost reforms that overlap with White House rhetoric on lowering prices. [1, 2, 3]

  • Expanding Drug Price Negotiations. Democrats plan to push legislation expanding Medicare prescription drug price negotiations to the commercial insurance market and reversing OBBBA exemptions for certain orphan drugs.
  • Hospital and PBM Reforms. Lawmakers can pursue bipartisan bills targeting Pharmacy Benefit Manager (PBM) pricing practices, enforcing hospital price transparency, and equalizing Medicare payments so procedures cost the same regardless of whether they are performed at a hospital outpatient department or an independent doctor’s office. [1, 2, 3, 4]
  1. Congressional Oversight and Subpoena Power

With control of House and Senate committees, Democrats gain full investigative authority to check executive branch actions at the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). [1, 2]

  • Scrutinizing Agency Actions. Committees can hold public hearings and subpoena records regarding HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s policies, including changes to federal vaccine schedules, public health messaging, and the management of federal scientific grants.
  • Slowing Regulatory Rollbacks. Aggressive oversight can expose implementation flaws in new Medicaid work rules and ACA enrollment barriers, building public pressure on the administration to issue administrative waivers or enforcement delays.
    [1, 2, 3, 4]

 

I enjoy playing the domino game, “Mexican Train.” On some rounds you draw a “slam dunk” hand where the only way to lose is to make an unforced error. What really gives me the most pleasure is doing well with a not-so-perfect hand. Those wins are usually gained through a combination of strategy and unexpected good fortune, either from the luck of the draw or from an unforced error by another player. My guess is that for good things to happen for healthcare over the next two years, the Democrats will need good strategies which will include a high degree of compromise and alignment within the party, and compromise across the aisle with moderate Republicans, plus a little luck of the draw from external events or more of the unforced errors by the president like going deeper into the war with Iran, or letting Stephen Miller run amok, because to overcome a presidential veto a two-thirds vote is required in both Houses of Congress. That is 290 votes in the House and 67 votes in the Senate, which means they will need 11 Republican Senators and about 30 Republican members of the House to have the courage to stand up to the president.  

 

Nevertheless, I was a little disappointed that ChatGPT couldn’t direct us to a secret passage the Democrats could use to bypass the president. What we learn from ChatGPT is that the Democrats come to the fight with Trump with the equivalent of a legislative gun with a few bullets. They can use investigations to “soften” up Trump’s resistance. They can use the power of the purse to deny funding to some of the president’s domestic and foreign adventures. They can pass laws that Trump will veto, with Republican votes sustaining the veto; those actions can be used in the next election in pursuit of even larger majorities that might have endurance, and finally there is the outside possibility that some Republicans will begin to see the wisdom of abandoning their fealty to the president and his dwindling MAGA coalition and join with Democrats to craft bipartisan bills to restore much of what we have lost as they begin to rebuild a viable Republican Party. There seem to be no other options. The last thing I would like to see them do is to impeach the president or remove him with the Twenty-Fifth Amendment because both would empower J.D. Vance and rescue him from the hole that he has dug for himself. 

 

The next big step for the Democrats is to decide who will be the Senate Majority Leader. I think that the competition for the post will force both Schumer and Van Hollen to sell their colleagues on the strategies they would employ. We may not be privy to the discussions before the choice is made, but I am interested in hearing the outcome. In the interim, I will continue to hope for unforced errors from the president, and for self-discipline from the Democrats who are totally capable of their own unforced errors, and we are all vulnerable to events beyond everyone’s control in our uncertain world. May the force be with us. 

 

The Force Was Not With My Wife and Me

 

If you had travel plans last weekend, you were likely affected by the four-hour halt in all flights last Friday afternoon. Even after the restriction was lifted, it took days for the system to fully recover from the nationwide service interruption. Except for the Secretary of Homeland Security, the Honorable Markwayne Mullin, a former professional wrestler, plumber, and U.S. Senator from Oklahoma, it took a long time for the rest of us traveling to reach our destinations.

 

My wife and I were impacted. We had reservations for Saturday to fly to Birmingham, Alabama, where we were meeting our “California son,” his wife, and their two boys, our grandsons. We were converging to attend a memorial event for my daughter-in-law’s mother, who had recently died after a two-year struggle with ALS.

 

My son’s wife grew up in Birmingham, where her father was a violinist with the Alabama Symphony for more than 30 years before retiring. They are not “native” Southerners, but have found a community of progressive souls that made living in a foreign environment tolerable. Her father’s family moved around the upper Midwest with most of their roots in Michigan. Her mother was also a talented musician and a super enthusiastic Cubs fan from the Chicago area. 

 

Getting to Birmingham from New England is not an easy trip. We were routed from Manchester to Birmingham via a plane change in Orlando, which, to me, seemed like “going around your elbow to get to your thumb.” We heaved a big sigh of relief when we departed Manchester with almost no delay. We had a comfortable two-hour transition scheduled for Orlando before finishing the trip to Birmingham. We did need to arrive in Birmingham before 10 PM because we had prepaid for a rental car and the office closed at 10. We had also prepaid our hotel reservations, which could not be canceled. We grew increasingly nervous as one delay after another was announced.

 

Ironically, the Birmingham flight was a “turnaround.” I was relieved when it finally landed, and we assumed that the return leg was imminent. Not so. There was a pilot, a copilot, and two stewardesses, but apparently they could not fly back until there were three flight attendants. I don’t know how they lost one of their three on the way down. My guess is that there was some sort of rule that determined how many hours a day she/he could work, and the clock was up. I then began to hear over the public address system that other flights were also delayed for a lack of personnel. There was an air of despair throughout the terminal.

 

Around 11:30 PM, long after any hope of getting our rental car had faded, I inquired whether there was a flight we could switch to the next day. I was delighted to discover that there were two seats left on the same 7:30 PM flight the next day. There were no seats on earlier flights. Now we had an uncertain circumstance that required a decision despite the ambiguity of the moment. Should we continue to wait in hopes of eventually flying, or opt to take the flight scheduled for 7:30 PM on Sunday, which would require finding a hotel room in Orlando at midnight and then spending most of Sunday sitting in the Orlando airport waiting for an evening flight? We opted for the next-day flight.

 

I later learned that our original flight did leave for Birmingham shortly before 1 AM. Meanwhile, we had found a comfortable room at a Marriott Hotel with shuttle service to and from the airport. The hotel agreed to extend our stay until 2 PM, which meant that we only needed to sit in the very crowded Orlando airport for about six hours on Sunday since our flight was again delayed.

 

Despite the delay, we did get to the car rental office at the Birmingham airport a few minutes before it closed so that we were able to get to our hotel a day late. I figure that, overall, our extended adventure cost us something like $500-600, and, more importantly, a day with family. The memorial gathering was scheduled for Tuesday afternoon at the Birmingham Botanical Gardens. About 15 members of the Alabama Symphony provided lovely music, and after many moving speeches and good food, the event morphed into a contradance. Contradancing was my daughter-in-law’s mother’s favorite activity, and she had planned her own celebration of life. 

 

In reflection, it seems to me that poor public policy and less-than-optimal management had a lot to do with our Orlando disaster. The airline delays were due to system failures precipitated by delayed upgrades and faulty repairs to a very old and inadequate air traffic control system. Even after the system was up and running, we were still vulnerable because workforce issues and overbooking, which were probably a function of efforts to increase profitability at the risk of poor service, would also seem likely. Perhaps cost-cutting decisions on labor, plus overbooking, were an attempt to compensate for dramatically increased fuel costs. It is easy to imagine that our care system is equally vulnerable to the same failures of infrastructure abuse and ill-advised cost-cutting strategies as our airline industry. I am happy to report that by Wednesday, our airline system was performing better, and we had an efficient trip from Birmingham to San Jose.

 

Today’s header is another celebration of the redwoods that I love. It captures a large redwood burl, evidence of healing from a previous injury. My son’s yard and his entire neighborhood are part of an ancient coastal redwood forest along the San Lorenzo River about ten miles northeast of Santa Cruz. We are here for Grandfriends’ Day at our grandsons’ school in Santa Cruz. 

 

The redwoods escaped total elimination over a hundred years ago because people who care about the environment took the steps necessary to prevent their wanton harvesting for short-term profits. One of the first efforts to save the redwoods eventually resulted in the establishment of Henry Cowell Redwoods State Park. The entrance is about a quarter mile from our son’s home. Those environmentalists were part of a progressive era that should remind us that caring about preserving and enhancing what is good is superior to maximizing shareholder benefits. The concept of preserving and protecting what is valuable and hard to replace is as appropriate to the future of healthcare as it is to the environment. In the end, everything is connected.

Be well,

Gene